Subway logo
Subway
Write a Review|3.1|

Subway Employee Reviews in Sheboygan, WI

Employee Insights in Sheboygan, WI

Review information last updated March 4, 2026.

Rating Distribution

1 rating

Summary of Subway Employee Feedback (AI-Generated)

Limited data available for your filters. Using broader results.
1.7 out of 5

Across the five Subway locations in Wisconsin, represented by these limited employee reviews, a consistent and concerning theme emerges: issues with management and a perceived lack of value for employees.
The most prevalent complaint revolves around inconsistent management support, with several locations reporting a shift in management support negatively impacting team morale and recognition of effort.
This includes instances of disregard for employee availability, encouragement of personal phone use, and a general lack of proactive recognition for employee contributions.
Compensation and recognition are frequently cited as key concerns, with multiple reviews describing employees feeling underpaid and underappreciated.
While the Oshkosh location offers a more positive experience, primarily due to its role as a ‘great first job’ and good work-life balance, the other locations consistently highlight deficiencies in management practices.
A significant number of reviews (Roberts, Adams, and Siren) indicate a disconnect between employee expectations and the reality of the job, with employees feeling undervalued and lacking opportunities for career advancement.
The Siren location particularly emphasizes a transactional employment experience with minimal investment in employee well-being.
The overall picture is one of a need for improved management training, more robust systems for recognizing employee contributions, and a greater emphasis on creating a supportive and engaging work environment.
The fact that the Oshkosh location is the only one with a high rating suggests that a specific operational approach or employee onboarding process might be contributing to a more positive experience, warranting further investigation.

Disclaimer: This review has been generated by AI based on employee feedback. It may not fully represent the company under the current filters. The AI attempts to analyze patterns in reviews but may not capture all nuances of the workplace experience.

Due to limited data for your exact filter criteria, this summary includes broader results.

Highlights

Pros

  • Company-Provided Subscription Benefits (Mentioned in Sheboygan)
  • Good Work-Life Balance (Oshkosh)
  • Suitable for Entry-Level Workers (Oshkosh)
  • Potentially Fast-Paced Work Environment (Implied by Adams' 'Fast Food' role)

Cons

  • Shift in Management Support
  • Lack of Recognition of Effort
  • Disregard for Employee Availability
  • Encouragement of Personal Phone Use
  • Underpaid Compensation
Feb 15, 2025
2 out of 5
Shift Leader

The free lunch is a wonderful benefit.

While I appreciated the company-provided subscription benefits, my overall experience was impacted by a shift in management support. Compensation was satisfactory, but I felt my efforts and work ethic were not consistently recognized or valued. I consistently invested my time and energy in training my team to the best of my ability.

Share Subway Company Reviews

All employee reviews are sourced from Employers.io users, trusted partners, and publicly available information. Opinions expressed in reviews reflect individual experiences and do not represent official statements from Subway. Contact us to suggest updates to this page.